I knew I had to include pizza - the turtles' favorite food, with absolutely no anchovies! I made the pizza out of modeling chocolate, and even grated a small piece of white modeling chocolate to create the "cheese."
I also made an authentic New York sewer grate, and of course the four turtles! Double awesome points if you can name all four!
The cake layers were lime - bright green turtle color, with homemade lime curd filling and lime Swiss meringue buttercream. Then I covered the cake in homemade vanilla fondant and impressed and hand painted a turtle shell design.
It was so fun to make this cake! Now I need a He-Man and She-Ra order... anyone??